In Leo Tolstoy’s works, jealousy is not merely an ordinary emotion that emerges in romantic relationships. The author examines jealousy through love, possessiveness, insecurity, sexuality, social norms, and the individual’s relationship with the self. Therefore, Tolstoy’s jealous characters cannot simply be understood as people who fear losing someone they love. Their behavior also reflects anxiety about the self, the desire for control, and emotional dependence.
In particular, Anna Karenina and The Kreutzer Sonata offer important examples of how jealousy can transform human psychology. Anna’s jealousy toward Vronsky gradually intensifies, while Pozdnyshev, the narrator of The Kreutzer Sonata, takes jealousy to the point of murder. Thus, Tolstoy explores how jealousy can initially appear intertwined with love but gradually turn into suspicion, anger, and destructive possessiveness.
From this perspective, jealousy in Tolstoy’s works extends beyond an individual emotion. It also becomes a narrative device through which the author questions the concept of marriage, relations between men and women, and possessive forms of love in nineteenth-century Russian society.
How Does Jealousy Emerge in Tolstoy’s Works?
Tolstoy’s jealous characters often experience fear of loss first. However, this fear soon develops into distrust toward another person.
A jealous person cannot evaluate the behavior of the other person objectively. A small glance, a delayed response, or a social interaction can become a major threat in the jealous person’s imagination. As a result, the boundary between reality and assumption gradually disappears.
Tolstoy is particularly interested in this psychological transformation. Jealousy does not necessarily require objective evidence. In fact, a jealous character may accept possibilities created by the imagination as if they were facts.
For this reason, jealousy creates a kind of distortion of perception in Tolstoy’s narratives. The individual no longer sees the external world as it is. Instead, the person sees a world shaped by fear.
Jealousy in Anna Karenina
One of the works in which Tolstoy explores jealousy most extensively is Anna Karenina. The relationship between Anna and Count Vronsky begins with an intense sense of love. Over time, however, the emotional balance within the relationship changes.
Anna’s fundamental fear concerns the possibility of losing Vronsky’s love. This fear gradually develops into jealousy. In the final sections of the novel, Anna begins to believe that Vronsky’s love for her has diminished. She also becomes increasingly concerned that he may develop an interest in other women. Tolstoy demonstrates here that jealousy does not necessarily have to focus on a specific rival. Anna ultimately becomes jealous of the possibility that Vronsky’s love might diminish.
This detail is significant because Anna’s jealousy stems less from an actual external threat than from her fear about the future of the relationship.
Uncertainty in Anna’s Jealousy
Uncertainty plays a major role in Anna’s psychology. Vronsky’s behavior does not always indicate actual infidelity. Nevertheless, Anna fills the gaps created by uncertainty with her own fears.
For example, Vronsky’s encounters with other women generate new scenarios in Anna’s mind. Consequently, her jealousy does not remain directed toward one particular person. Potential rivals constantly change.
Tolstoy reveals an important characteristic of jealousy at this point: Jealousy can change its object while preserving the insecurity at its source.
Vronsky’s Jealousy and Possessiveness
Vronsky is not entirely free from jealousy either. However, his jealousy does not become as constant and destructive as Anna’s.
Although Vronsky loves Anna, he tries to balance his relationship with her against his social position, career, and desire for independence. Anna, meanwhile, connects almost all of her emotional security to Vronsky’s love.
Therefore, an important difference emerges between the jealousy of the two characters. Vronsky is primarily concerned with the boundaries of the relationship, whereas Anna constantly feels that the relationship itself remains under threat.
Thus, Tolstoy presents two different forms of jealousy within the same love affair. On one side stands the tension between possessiveness and independence; on the other stands the fear of abandonment.
The Kreutzer Sonata: The Most Destructive Form of Jealousy
Tolstoy examines jealousy in its most severe form in The Kreutzer Sonata. Pozdnyshev stands at the center of this novella.
Pozdnyshev suspects that his wife has a relationship with a musician. His suspicion gradually intensifies and ultimately leads him to murder his wife. Scholars have examined the work particularly in relation to jealousy, sexuality, anger, and moral judgment.
Here, Tolstoy does not treat jealousy merely as a romantic emotion. He examines it as one of the psychological mechanisms that can contribute to violence.
Pozdnyshev repeatedly blurs the boundary between reality and assumption. He interprets his wife’s behavior through the lens of his own suspicions. As a result, jealousy becomes less an observation of reality than a psychological projection.
Pozdnyshev: The Psychology of Jealousy
It would be insufficient to explain Pozdnyshev’s jealousy simply as “fear of losing his wife.”
Sexuality, masculinity, marriage, possessiveness, and morality become intertwined in his thoughts. Consequently, jealousy becomes not only an emotional issue but also an ideological one.
Pozdnyshev interprets the possibility of his wife becoming close to another man as a threat to his own conception of masculinity. Jealousy therefore connects personal insecurity with social ideas about gender.
Contemporary scholarship has likewise emphasized the relationship between anger, hatred, jealousy, and moral judgment in The Kreutzer Sonata.
Jealousy and Possessiveness in Tolstoy
In Tolstoy’s works, there is not always a clear boundary between love and possessiveness.
When a character fears losing someone they love, they may begin to control that person. As the desire for control increases, the freedom of the other person comes under threat.
Consequently, love can cease to function as a relationship based on mutual trust and move toward a sense of ownership.
Tolstoy’s criticism becomes particularly clear at this point. Through the actions of his characters, he reveals the difference between “I love you” and “I want to possess you.”
For this reason, jealousy in Tolstoy’s fictional world does not simply indicate the intensity of love. Instead, it can indicate that love has developed into an unhealthy form.
Jealousy and Relations Between Men and Women
Gender relations occupy an important place in Tolstoy’s treatment of jealousy.
In works such as Anna Karenina and The Kreutzer Sonata, marriage does not function merely as a private relationship between two individuals. Social expectations, sexual morality, and the position of women also shape the relationship.
In particular, contemporary studies of The Kreutzer Sonata emphasize the controversial aspects of the work concerning female sexuality and gender.
From this perspective, Pozdnyshev’s jealousy cannot be understood solely through individual psychology. His ideas about women and marriage should also be examined in relation to the patriarchal norms of his period.
How Does Jealousy Change the Perception of Reality?
Jealousy has another important function in Tolstoy’s narrative technique: it changes the perception of reality.
A jealous character sees events through an emotional filter. Therefore, the reader must establish a distance between the character’s perception and the actual events.
Narrative studies of The Kreutzer Sonata, in particular, have emphasized how the perspective of a jealous character can make the meaning of events ambiguous.
Through this technique, Tolstoy directs the reader not only toward the question, “What actually happened?”, but also toward the question, “Why does a person perceive reality in this way?”
Jealousy, Anger, and Violence
Tolstoy’s treatment of jealousy establishes a strong chain between several emotions:
Love → Fear of Loss → Suspicion → Jealousy → Anger → Desire for Control → Violence
This chain does not produce the same outcome in every character. However, in The Kreutzer Sonata, the process reaches a fatal conclusion.
Pozdnyshev’s story represents an extreme example. Jealousy becomes stronger when the individual refuses to question personal emotions and instead blames the other person.
Tolstoy therefore does not locate the source of violence solely in external circumstances. The hostility that the character constructs within his own mind also plays a significant role.
Why Are Tolstoy’s Jealous Characters Important?
Tolstoy’s jealous characters hold an important place in the development of the modern psychological novel. The author examines not only what his characters do but also the mental processes behind their actions.
Anna’s jealousy gradually narrows her emotional world. Pozdnyshev’s jealousy, meanwhile, destroys his sense of reality and moral judgment.
Through these characters, Tolstoy raises an important question:
Does a person become jealous because they truly love someone, or because they want to protect themselves from the fear of loss?
Tolstoy does not provide a simple answer. Instead, he demonstrates how jealousy becomes intertwined with love, fear, desire, pride, and possessiveness.
Conclusion
In Tolstoy’s novels and novellas, jealousy goes beyond being a simple romantic emotion. The author examines jealousy through psychological insecurity, possessiveness, sexuality, gender, and morality.
In Anna Karenina, Anna’s jealousy grows out of her fear of losing love. Moreover, this fear does not require a specific rival; even the possibility that Vronsky’s love might diminish becomes sufficient to intensify her jealousy.
In The Kreutzer Sonata, Pozdnyshev represents the most destructive form of jealousy. Suspicion, anger, and possessiveness combine and eventually lead to violence. Scholarship likewise regards the novella as an important literary text for examining the psychological and ethical dimensions of jealousy.
Ultimately, Tolstoy presents jealousy not as proof of love but, in many cases, as a symptom of insecurity that enters into love. His characters reveal a fundamental problem: when an individual cannot recognize the person they love as an autonomous human being, love can easily turn into possessiveness. This insight explains much of the enduring significance of Tolstoy’s treatment of jealousy in modern literature.
References
- Bénézech, M. (1994). “The Kreutzer Sonata or Homicidal Jealousy According to Tolstoy.” Annales Médico-Psychologiques, 152(5), 281–291.
- Ellis, K. (1971). “Ambiguity and Point of View in Some Novelistic Representations of Jealousy.” Modern Language Notes, 86(5), 891–909.
- Herman, D. (2017). “Stricken by Infection: Art and Adultery in Anna Karenina and Kreutzer Sonata.” Slavic Review.
- Pettman, D. (2013). “Tolstoy’s Bestiary: Animality and Animosity in The Kreutzer Sonata.” Angelaki, 18(1), 121–138.
- Wyman, A. (2015). “Discourse and Intercourse in The Kreutzer Sonata: A Schelerian Perspective.” Christianity & Literature, 64(2), 147–170.
- Tolstoy, L. N. (1877). Anna Karenina.
- Tolstoy, L. N. (1889). The Kreutzer Sonata.
- Karabacak, E. (2023). “A Study of Leo Tolstoy’s The Kreutzer Sonata in the Context of Feminist Literary Criticism.” RumeliDE Journal of Language and Literature Studies, 34.
- Páteo, J. F. D. (2024). “Tolstoy and Women’s Sexuality: An Analysis of the Female Characters in Family Happiness, Anna Karenina and Kreutzer Sonata.” RUS (São Paulo).
